Skip to main content
Article

When ex­ec­ut­ive man­age­ment says yes and em­ploy­ees say no

New research from CBS shows why organisational change can stall even when it is a high priority for the executive management. A five-year study of a pharmaceutical company suggests that new functions only really gain a foothold when employees feel that they solve problems that matter in their day-to-day work

Author

Kent Kristensen

“It is your playground. You can do anything.”

That was the unequivocal message from the executive management to the new procurement director at a European pharmaceutical company when he was tasked with transforming the company’s procurement unit from an administrative support function into a strategic business partner.

But elsewhere in the organisation, the reaction was very different.
"Forget it," was the response when the procurement director visited the other divisions.

The contrast between these two reactions is central to a new study led by CBS Professor Kim Sundtoft Hald. Over five years, he and two former CBS students followed an international pharmaceutical company’s efforts to give its procurement function a much more strategic role. 

“I think the pattern will be familiar to many other shared functions, such as IT, HR and finance, but we have not studied that.” Kim Sundtoft Hald
Professor

Broad mandate, little impact

“What surprised us was how little impact such a clear mandate from the executive management had across the organisation. We had expected support from management to matter more. It was necessary, but it was nowhere near enough,” says Kim Sundtoft Hald. 

The problem was that employees further down the organisation could not see how they benefited from the new structure, which gave the procurement unit far greater authority than before to set procurement rules across the large company. 

This was the case even though the company was saving money.

“A mandate from the executive management is not the same as acceptance. They can give a unit or division the authority to act, but acceptance has to be earned across the organisation,” says Kim Sundtoft Hald.

Authority caused frustration

The company had a decentralised culture, stringent quality and safety requirements and very solid professional environments. 

From the perspective of colleagues in offices and laboratories, the procurement unit’s new authority did not necessarily look helpful. Instead, it looked like a licence to interfere with decisions that researchers and production employees believed they themselves were best qualified to make.

The travel policy was a case in point. A consultancy firm had been brought in from the outset to help streamline procurement. Among the results was a standard model with narrow booking windows and specified airlines.

“But employees also went on long and complicated trips in connection with clinical trials. Plans could change at short notice, so employees felt that the standardised solution was out of touch with reality,” explains Kim Sundtoft Hald.

The crucial turning point

The resistance eventually forced procurement employees to change their strategy.

They gradually moved away from the idea of rolling out new structures and procedures across the entire organisation, and instead they began building relationships and solving specific problems together with employees.

The crucial turning point came in December 2017.

Senior Management launched a new growth strategy that directly linked greater efficiency to the company’s ability to fund innovation and growth.

Same exercise, new meaning

The company still needed to identify savings and work more efficiently, but the meaning changed. Employees could now see that the savings were intended to fund growth, 

and that meant funding something they themselves considered important: research, innovation and ultimately their work with patients. 

“They now saw the same initiatives as a help rather than a threat. Financial arguments are not irrelevant, but they only really work when employees can see that those arguments serve something they themselves care deeply about,” says Kim Sundtoft Hald.

He points out that employees accept change in a particular sequence.  First, the change must make sense in relation to what employees consider important. Second, it must deliver tangible results. Third, it becomes a habit that no one questions any longer. 

Clinical trials provided tangible proof

The new approach demonstrated its value when the procurement function helped renegotiate contracts with external suppliers providing services for clinical trials.

The result was not only lower costs; the agreements also led to better service levels. As a result, the procurement function was no longer associated solely with controlling expenditure; it was contributing to something that directly benefited the specialist units’ own projects. 

“This shows that you cannot simply declare yourself strategic, but you can become strategic by solving problems that other people have. Procurement moved from rolling out structures to saying: “I am not here to outsource you, I am here to help.” That humility was an investment, not a defeat,” says Kim Sundtoft Hald, pointing to a surprising development:

The rest of the organisation ended up asking the procurement unit for more services than it could provide. 

Only go deep where it matters 

This leads to another of the study’s conclusions. As Kim Sundtoft Hald puts it, it is better to go deep where it matters than to spread yourself thin everywhere. In the study, the researchers call this selective institutionalisation.

“In our case, this meant that the procurement unit became a natural part of day-to-day operations in areas such as travel, logistics and the procurement of services for clinical trials, but the unit was deliberately kept out of other areas because the specialists needed to make the decisions there.  What worked was standardising where risk and rules required it and allowing freedom where professional judgement was essential,” says Kim Sundtoft Hald, adding: 

“When the same template is imposed on everyone, specialists see it as a sign of mistrust and shadow processes emerge. I think the pattern will be familiar to many other shared functions such as IT, HR and finance, but we have not studied that.”

About the study

Study: Institutional dynamics of purchasing and supply management development: A process study of stakeholder influence

Authors: Kim Sundtoft Hald, Petra Andrea Szuromi and Ida Helene Andersen.

Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management, 2026. 

Data: The study follows one European pharmaceutical company over five years and draws on 17 interviews with 10 people as well as 138 internal documents.

Key findings:

  • A mandate is not the same as acceptance. 
  • Acceptance develops in a particular sequence. 
  • Savings alone are not persuasive. 
  • Success does not mean everyone following the same process.

About the re­search­er

  • Kim Sundtoft Hald is a professor at the Department of Operations Management at CBS.

     

  • His main research and teaching areas include supply chain management, performance management, operations management, process optimisation, sustainable processes, resilient processes, process digitalisation, procurement management as well as the management of business-to-business relationships and supplier networks.