Skip to main content
Article

Man­agers should know the dark sides of em­pathy

Empathy can be used in different ways, with both positive and negative outcomes. More managers need to understand how they practise and perceive empathy in their organisations. This is the conclusion of a new study by CBS researchers examining four dark sides of empathy.

Leadership
Author

CBS Efteruddannelse

Empathetic leadership. A buzzword in management research over the past ten years. The more a manager can understand and value employees’ emotions, the better.

But the reality is far from that simple. Empathy is not always a positive quality.

“It can be a good thing, but it can also be problematic. And it is extremely important that managers learn how to use empathy consciously,” says Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen, Associate Professor at CBS and one of the authors of the new study on empathy.

Together with her colleagues, she has examined a range of research papers on empathy and how it is perceived and practised in different organisations.

“Empathy is complex and not inherently good or moral. It can have negative consequences if practised without careful consideration of its downsides,” Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen adds.

This is a point she also shares with students in the management courses she teaches at CBS Executive Education.

Being able to listen to others, put yourself in their shoes and show care is also more than simply a personality trait in leaders.

“Empathy emerges in relationships between people. And the way empathy is distributed is deeply connected to gender and power. That is why it is crucial to understand how to practise empathy in management,” Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen explains.

Can lead to mental overload

The CBS researchers identify four dark sides of empathy.

The first concerns the risk of emotional strain when practising empathy.

When you listen to someone who is stressed or struggling, it can trigger an emotional response not only in the person telling their story, but also in the person listening.

“The person lending an ear can end up feeling drained and mentally overloaded. There may even be a physical reaction where you feel tired and heavy,” Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen says.

Professionals such as doctors, psychologists, nurses and social workers who work with people who are often facing difficult and painful situations should be particularly aware of how they use empathy.

“In these professions, managers and the organisation as a whole have a significant responsibility to support employees and prevent them from becoming overwhelmed or exhausted by too much emotional and empathetic work,” Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen elaborates.

“Managers should pay attention to whom they are inclined to show empathy and who does not receive it to the same extent. This also applies when they are recruiting or promoting employees.” Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen
Associate Professor at CBS

Empathy can cause inequality

Another important aspect of empathy concerns inequality and who takes on the empathetic work.

Women are more likely than men to take on empathetic work in an organisation. For example, they help student assistants settle in, listen to colleagues’ personal stories about losing loved ones and take greater responsibility for creating a positive working environment, Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen explains.

When men show empathy, it is perceived as something extra and positive. As a result, they receive far more recognition from managers and colleagues than their female colleagues do.

When women show empathy in the workplace, however, it is more likely to be taken for granted and seen as something that comes naturally with motherhood. Consequently, it does not result in the same positive recognition.

Managers should therefore be aware of potential biases and gain a clear picture of who is taking on most of the empathetic work. They should also recognise this work, whether through pay, promotion or praise.

“They should be aware that when Sarah shows empathy, it is often less noticeable than when Michael does the same,” Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen says.

She also recommends that managers use staff development dialogues to gain insight into who is actually doing the relational work in the organisation.

“We have to remember that empathy is real work that contributes positively to the organisation as a whole.”

Selective empathy can be problematic

A third aspect worth considering when it comes to empathy in the workplace is who receives it.

“We find it easier to care about people who are similar to ourselves. For example, people who look like us, share our values or belong to the same social class,” says Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen.

This means that empathy is often selective and directed towards colleagues who are similar to the manager in these respects.

“Managers should pay attention to whom they are inclined to show empathy and who does not receive it to the same extent. This also applies when they are recruiting or promoting employees,” Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen says, and she adds that executive education programmes can be an effective way to gain insight into your own biases relating to gender and ethnicity.

Manipulating empathy

The final aspect highlighted by the CBS researchers in their study is how empathy can be used to manipulate others.

We all use our innate ability to read and interpret how other people feel and what they need in order to achieve our own goals.

Managers may consciously use this human ability to create loyalty and gain support from employees.

“When a manager listens to employees and shows that they care, it can increase employees’ desire to perform and their motivation,” Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen explains.

There is nothing inherently wrong with that. It is not a form of deception, the associate professor explains.

However, there is a tipping point. Managers with narcissistic traits or a highly dominant leadership style may use emotional information about employees for their own benefit.

“If they use information about someone to achieve a specific goal, such as gaining support during a serious internal issue, it becomes manipulative behaviour.”

Managers should therefore take a good look at themselves and be mindful of how they use empathy and for what purpose.

“Employees should also be aware of this power dynamic and the potential for manipulation,” Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen says.

Empathy is not bad but should be used wisely

Empathy is not a bad thing, Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen emphasises.

“You just have to understand how to use it and why. That is why we encourage managers to recognise empathy as a real competence and reward it accordingly,” Elisabeth Naima Mikkelsen says.

“Managers also need to be aware of gender biases, as well as the power and responsibility they have to distribute empathy fairly and consciously among employees,” she adds.

Your gate­way to more know­ledge

Did you find this content interesting? Sign up for our newsletter and gain access to more of our research findings and events. 

With the world’s grand challenges awaiting us, we need to continuously evolve, gain new knowledge and insights, and upskill.

Dive into a world of knowledge by signing up below. You will get:

  • Personal event invitations
  • Pertinent research-based insights on business and society
  • Information about the next intakes of our Executive Education programmes and courses